The Sniff Test — Why Dogs Choose Fresh Treats Over Processed

The Sniff Test — Why Dogs Choose Fresh Treats Over Processed

Ever noticed how your dog gives a sniff before every bite — even when they’ve had the same treat 100 times before?

That’s because for dogs, taste starts with smell. And when it comes to treats, they can sniff out the difference between real food and fake fillers in a heartbeat.

At Snappy Snacks, we’ve learned one thing over the years:
If it doesn’t pass the sniff test, it won’t pass the tail-wag test either. Here’s why.

1. A Dog’s Nose Knows — Literally

Dogs have up to 300 million scent receptors in their noses (humans only have about 5 million). That’s why they can:

  • Detect a treat from two rooms away

  • Smell the difference between fresh oats and stale biscuits

  • Pick out their favourite flavour from a pile

So when you hand them a mass-produced treat full of preservatives?
Yeah... they smell that too.

2. Why Freshness Smells Better to Dogs

Freshly baked treats contain:

  • Natural oils from peanuts, seeds, and fruit

  • Real ingredients that haven’t been stripped of scent

  • Moisture that carries aroma to their sensitive noses

In contrast, highly processed treats are:

  • Cooked at high temps that destroy aroma compounds

  • Preserved with chemicals that smell artificial

  • Packed for months in plastic or foil

Dogs may still eat them out of habit — but they’ll often ignore them when given something better.

3. What Dogs Actually Want From a Treat (Hint: It’s Not Colour or Shape)

Humans care about packaging. Dogs care about smell.

Most commercial brands add colours or cute shapes to appeal to us — but dogs couldn’t care less. What matters to them is:

  • Smell intensity

  • Familiar, “real food” scents (peanut butter, apple, oats)

  • Textures that match the scent expectation (soft for banana, crunchy for chia)

This is why simple, oven-baked treats win every time.

4. Our Treats Pass the Sniff Test — and Then Some

At Snappy Snacks, we bake in small batches using real, aromatic ingredients:

  • Roasted peanut butter = warm, rich scent

  • Chia + banana = naturally sweet aroma

  • Oats = comforting, familiar base (think porridge!)

Because our treats aren’t overprocessed, they retain their natural smell — and dogs know it the second you open the bag.

🐶 “The moment I get the treat out of the box, Archie comes running. He never did that for supermarket stuff!”
— Laura S., Devon

5. Try This at Home: The Treat Sniff-Off

Want to see for yourself?

Try this little game:

  1. Lay out 2–3 different treats (including one of ours 😉).

  2. Let your dog approach and choose freely.

  3. Watch their nose go to work.

Most dogs will sniff around — but 9 times out of 10, they’ll choose the freshest, most aromatic option. We’ve seen it happen at markets time and time again.


🛍️ Smell the Love: Our Most Aromatic Favourites

👉 Puppynut butter – high smell, low fat
👉 Ginger wag– ideal for fussy sniffers
👉Healthy champs – a little of everything, for the ultimate sniff test

Final Thought

Dogs live through their noses.
If a treat doesn’t smell right, they won’t get excited. If it smells like real food — fresh, warm, and wholesome — they’ll come running.

That’s the Snappy Snacks difference. We bake for dogs, but we respect their noses.

So next time your dog sniffs before chewing?
Give them something worth sniffing for. 🐾

Stay snappy,
Karen ,Trevor and Boa
Snappy Snacks

Back to blog